LILYDALE STAR MAIL
Home » News » Claim machete bins cost the government $325,000 is false

Claim machete bins cost the government $325,000 is false



WHAT WAS CLAIMED

Victoria’s machete disposal bins cost $325,000 each.

OUR VERDICT

False. The calculation method for the bin costs is incorrect. The government says the bins cost around $2400 each.

AAP FACTCHECK – Federal and state politicians are falsely claiming machete disposal bins installed across Victoria cost $325,000 each – or about the same as a Ferrari.

The figure has been miscalculated, dividing the $13 million budget for the entire machete amnesty program (which also includes an educational campaign and public awareness drive) by the number of bins installed across the state.

The Victorian government told AAP FactCheck the bins cost about $2400 each.

With a statewide ban on machetes now in force, the three-month amnesty scheme allows owners to dispose of their weapons anonymously.

Under the scheme, the government is funding education and awareness campaigns, the installation of machete deposit bins across the state, and plans for safe disposal.

The false claims about the cost of the bins have been made by the Victorian Liberal Party, including Opposition youth minister Nicole Werner.

In a Facebook video, Ms Werner compares the supposed $325,000 cost of each bin to a luxury sports car.

“$325,000 a pop – you could buy a Ferrari with that,” Ms Werner says. “$13 million for 40 bins – if you do the maths on that … that is $325,000 spent per bin, these bins that look like charity bins at an op shop.”

The Victorian Liberal Party has made the same claim on its Facebook page, while federal Liberal MP Jason Wood has also cited the figure in a widely shared post. “How could one machete bin cost $325K?!” Mr Wood says in a Facebook post dated 14 August 2025.

Croydon MP David Hodgett and Eildon MP Cindy McLeish also circulated the $13 million cost claim in social media posts.

The false claims have spread more widely on social media too, with a series of commentators repeating the $325,000 figure.

Neither Mr Wood nor Ms Werner responded to AAP FactCheck’s request for evidence, though Ms Werner does detail how the $325,000 was calculated in her post.

She divides the $13 million in funding allocated to the whole machete amnesty program in the 2025/26 Victorian budget by 40, which is close to the number of disposal bins (45) installed by the state government.

This method, however, drastically overestimates the cost of each bin because the $13 million program funding covers more than just the bins themselves. A briefing provided to Victoria’s Public Accounts and Estimates Committee in June 2025 details a series of other elements to be funded with the $13 million (page three), including a public awareness campaign and an education program focused on machete retailers.

The bins are a small part of the overall funding package, costing about $2400 each, data sent to AAP FactCheck by the Victorian government reveals.

AAP FactCheck requested further detail, including a detailed breakdown of how much each element of the scheme will cost, but no data was provided. As some elements of the program haven’t yet taken place, including the safe disposal of surrendered machetes, the final budget cost is unclear.

The $2400 price tag is, however, consistent with the price quoted online for steel charity bins by a prominent Victorian metal company.

The claim has also been addressed in the Victorian parliament, with acting speaker Daniela De Martino also citing the $2400 price per bin.

“The entire project, that $13 million, includes public awareness, retailer education, manufacturing and installation of the machete safe disposal bins,” she added (page 92).

AAP FactCheck is an accredited member of the International Fact-Checking Network. To keep up with our latest fact checks, follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Threads, X, BlueSky, TikTok and YouTube.

Digital Editions


More News

  • Councils call for Growing Suburbs Fund to be restored

    Councils call for Growing Suburbs Fund to be restored

    An ongoing push for the State Government to restore the Growing Suburbs Fund which supported tens of millions of dollars in infrastructure projects in Yarra Ranges and Cardinia is continuing.…

  • Democracy without freedom of speech?

    Democracy without freedom of speech?

    January is when we start easing back into our yearly routines. The chaos of Christmas behind us,. Xmas leftovers finally eaten; newly minted New Year resolutions most likely already breached,…

  • Hamnet deserved better at Golden Globes

    Hamnet deserved better at Golden Globes

    The 83rd Golden Globes took place on January 12, and I have mixed feelings about the results. Nikki Glaser hosted the ceremony for the second time this year, and once…

  • ‘A mockery’: Kangaroo shooting continues during bushfires

    ‘A mockery’: Kangaroo shooting continues during bushfires

    Wildlife rescuers are demanding the State Government put a halt to the commercial killing of kangaroos as countless animals lie burned and suffering in blackened smoldering forests. This year’s catastrophic…

  • Communications crucial in bushfire

    Communications crucial in bushfire

    It’s been a difficult and anxious week for many as bushfires rip through the state, inching close to our own community on Friday 10 January. Marked the worst fire danger…

  • Your Library locations closed for Australia Day

    Your Library locations closed for Australia Day

    All Your Library locations across the Yarra Ranges will be closed for the Australia Day public holiday on 26 January. Business will return to normal on Tuesday 27 January. The…

  • Lilydale Lakeside Writers Group

    Lilydale Lakeside Writers Group

    Lilydale Lakeside Writers Group A guest article by Leanne Margaret Christine’s Note: Many thanks to local author Leanne Margaret, of Croydon, for sharing her experiences and insights of hosting the…

  • Dark Times

    Dark Times

    Cartoonist Danny Zemp reflects on all the negativity in the world. Sometimes, you just need a hug.

  • Stay vigilant around water this long weekend

    Stay vigilant around water this long weekend

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 153243 Ambulance Victoria is urging people to take extra care in and around water this long weekend, as a spate of tragic drownings continue…

  • Thirsty? Here’s where you can get free water refills in the Yarra Ranges

    Thirsty? Here’s where you can get free water refills in the Yarra Ranges

    Caught with an empty drink bottle while you’re out in town? Thanks to Yarra Valley Water’s new Refiller Cafes map, you’ll always know where the closest spot is to stock…